Predaking
1) Arlington Road
2) Deathtrap
3) Starship Troopers
4) Road to Perdition
5) Go
6) Pitch Black
7) Thin Red Line
8) Ninth Gate
9) Undisputed
10) Last Man Standing
Not sure what your definition of "underrated" is, but if by underrated you mean praise from reviewers and box office returns, many of the movies on your list don't qualify.
1) Arlington Road
Nominated for three Saturn Awards
Total Gross: $24,362,501 domestic (not huge business, but its budget was only $21,500,000)
2) Are you referring to the Sidney Lumet directed Deathtrap?
3) Starship Troopers
Nominated for one Oscar
Nominated for five Saturn Awards, won two
Total Gross: $119,700,065 worldwide
4) Road To Perdition
Critcally Acclaimed
Nominated for six Oscars, won for best cinematography
Nominated for two Saturn Awards, won both
Total Gross: $161,354,514 worldwide
5) Go
Nominated for two Independent Spirit Awards
Total Gross: $16,842,303 domestic (more than twice its budget)
6) Pitch Black
Nominated for a Saturn Award
Gross: $39,235,088 domestic (just under twice its budget)
Was popular enough on dvd and cable to warrant a sequel
7) The Thin Red Line
Critcally Acclaimed
Nominated for seven Oscars
Total Gross: $81,600,000 worldwide
I agree with you on the others.
Predaking
I know there's probably a thread on this topic already... I'm too lazy to look for the old thread.
I'm not.