Funky_Guy
I only like Genesis stuff up till 1980's Duke album and I have to say I think most of 1979's And Then There Were Three is pretty weak. 1981's Abacab has a few cuts I don't mind but after the early 80's stuff they totally lose me and I've never liked any of Phil or Mike's solo stuff.
My favorite Genesis stuff is the Peter Gabriel era when Genesis were more of a pogressive rock band with elements of folk and psychadelic (1967 - 1975.) I also like a lot of Peter Gabriel's solo stuff and some of Steve Hackett and Tony Bank's solo stuff but I think Tony would have been wise to have worked intsturmental rather than bring in outside singers and trying to sing on some of his stuff.
I tooootally agree! I love Gabriel era Genesis! Foxtrot, Nursery Crime, Selling England By The Pound and The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway being some of my faves. I also adore Steve Hackett, I think I have pretty much all of his solo albums. I also couldn't agree with you more about Tony Banks. Everything I've heard of his, the music is stunning until the vocals kick in. I'm the same way about Steve Howe's solo stuff, sublime guitar work and stellar arrangements but when he tries to sing! Blech! Just shut up and play! Obviously I'm talking about Beginnings and not brilliant albums like The Steve Howe Album and Natural Timbre. O.k. I guess it's out now. I'm a prog fan. May as well throw King Crimson on the pile as they are also on my favored list. I simply adore Starless and Bible Black. I also love Islands but critics knock that one for some reason. Do I dare venture into Gentle Giant or is that going to far?
*EDIT* I meant to ask you since you brought up Phil Collins, if you like Brand X? It just makes it that much more sad when you here the schlock Phil Collins puts out now compared with the awesome stuff he did with Brand X.